Hot news:
Groundbreaking crop yielding technology: Kazakhstani scientists Sharm el-Sheikh - Almaty direct flights to open in summer 2014 Kazakhstan to subsidize agro-industry The Spirit of Tengri: taste of world ethnic music in Almaty Samsung Galaxy explodes in child's pocket in Kazakhstan Nazarbayev kickstarts construction of EXPO-2017 venue Condition of derailed train victims is satisfactory: Head Surgeon Kadyrov Three foreigners dead at Kabul hospital as guard opens fire Population of Kazakhstan's south to outnumber north four times Almaty avenue among world's most expensive streets Caspian Five to limit third party military forces in the region F1 boss Ecclestone's bribery trial starts in Germany All orphanages to close down in Kazakhstan Britain's Camilla 'devastated' by brother's death in fall Oscar winner Nyong'o named People's most beautiful Abe, Obama affirm Japan-US alliance at summit Strong 6.6 earthquake strikes off Canada's Vancouver island: USGS Saudi prince killed endangered birds France to send fighter jets for NATO Baltics patrols Apple splitting stock as iPhone sales soar US actress Jodie Foster marries girlfriend China frees Japan ship after $28 mn paid Three students killed by wall collapse in Portugal Canadian woman's letter arrives -- after 45-year delay Peru probes killing of endangered penguins Brazil passes trailblazing Internet privacy law Head of NCOC, Kashagan operating company, to resign Kazakhstan considering grain terminals along its borders on Turkmenistan and Iran Kazakhstan’s revenues for grain exports in 2013 exceed $1 billion 60% of Kazakhstanis support Russia on Ukrainian crisis Kazakhstan to launch its first ever remote sensing satellite from Kourou April 29 Repatriated Kazakhs to get Kazakhstan citizenship in 1 year Kazakh father of Boston prisoner granted US Visa Philippines' oldest artworks in danger of disappearing 60% of China underground water polluted Village turns into island in Kazakh steppe Kazakhstan is very concerned over Ukraine: Tokayev Kazakhstani writer Ilya Odegov wins Russian Award UK woman held for murder after children's bodies found Russia expels Canadian diplomat Judge's order on CIA secret prisons released in full UK revokes Ablyazov's refugee status US sending 600 troops to Poland, Baltics for drills Pentagon scientists show off life-size robot Brazil ex-leader Kubitschek was not murdered Fifty years of Mustang cool: is China along for the ride? Australia boosts air power with $11.6bn purchase of 58 F-35s Small French park becomes home for desperate Syrian families Balkhash lake named best place for nuclear power plant in Kazakhstan Pirates kidnap three on Singapore tanker off Malaysia Vienna's Versailles offers imperial hideaway Oscar show producers to return in 2015 Sri Lanka detains British tourist over Buddha tattoo GSK, Novartis unveil major healthcare revamp Death toll in South Korea ferry disaster crosses 100 Teen survives five-hour flight in airplane wheel well British corruption of minors case hearing in Uralsk postponed for one month Boston prisoners' legal proceedings may be postponed: Stall Full-scaled resumption of crude production at Kashagan expected at the end of 2015 Military parade due on May 7 in Astana Brunei delays introduction of tough Islamic law Kazakhstan movie in Cannes Festival programme Hitler, Kazakhstan and editorial struggle Passenger train derailed in Kazakhstan's west, 44 injured Biden meets Ukraine leaders as Russia, US swap blame on crumbling deal China's Shandong Airlines orders 50 Boeing planes for $4.6 bn South Korea says North may be close to nuclear test Kazakh chess princess Zhansaya Abdumalik takes 3rd place at Asia Continental Almaty Marathon raises $55 thousand for charity Juicy court case leaves Coca-Cola on defensive Formula One boss faces bribery charges in German trial Police arrest 250, seize weapons in Argentina Gladiators, horsemen help fete Rome's 2,767th birthday Powdered alcohol poised to hit US stores UN evacuates 100 Muslims from C. Africa capital Canadians rally to legalize marijuana Step aboard Orient Express for journey back in time Guides, climbers cancel Everest expeditions after tragedy Queen Elizabeth portrait released to mark 88th birthday President says ferry crew's actions 'tantamount to murder' Most Bangladesh factory survivors still too sick to work Tennis: Kazakhstani Zarina Diyas gets in WTA Top-100 Facebook wants to beam the Internet from the sky US judge dismisses Tarantino lawsuit against website Aspirin halves colon cancer risk -- if you have certain gene Hello Kitty mayhem returns to Singapore Obama says Russia not abiding by deal on Ukraine

Kazakhstan political analysts see no political motives in Prime Plaza clashes

02.09.2013
Opinion Opinion Commentary

Kazakhstan political analysts believe that the clashes at the concert near Prime Plaza in Almaty that left 90 wounded and hundreds scared had no political motives.

The incident that happened in Almaty on August 31 during a concert of a popular Kazakh singer Kairat Nurtas was in no way related to celebration of the Constitution Day or the wedding of Kazakhstan President’s grandson Aissultan Nazarbayev that happened the same day, the expert Marat Shibutov believes.

“I don’t think this was purposefully planned. This was just a combination of incompetence of the concert's hosts and the general degradation of the population that manifested themselves in the lack of behavioural culture,” Shibutov said. According to him, the uncontrolled spin of the mob was caused by a whole set of circumstances: poor choice of venue for the concert, insufficient number of security personnel, free entrance and gathering of unexpectedly large number of people.

Marat Shibutov. ©Tengrinews.kz

Marat Shibutov. ©Tengrinews.kz

Kazakhstan analyst Nurlan Yerimbetov has a similar opinion. He put it shortly: “This is a diagnosis: we are talking about marginalization of our young people. This is a problem far greater than a masterminded campaign.”

Nurlan Yerimbetov. ©Yaroslav Radlovskiy

Nurlan Yerimbetov. ©Yaroslav Radlovskiy

Analyst Rustam Burnashev also agreed that there was no political motives in the incident. “Judging from the information available in the media, we can talk about a coincidental combination of circumstances, poor organization of the event and improper behavior of the concert’s participants,” the expert said.

Rustam Burnashev. ©Yaroslav Radlovskiy

Rustam Burnashev. ©Yaroslav Radlovskiy

Director of Alternative Center for Topical Studies Andrey Chebotarev has a different opinion. He does not preclude that the incident was deliberately organized and orchestrated by someone: “I think that it was very well organized. It is possible that some forces interested in influencing the situation in the country orchestrated this incident -- that was a sort of a drill -- in preparation for arranging similar outbursts at critical times."

"Considering that the existing opposition has no such capacities and resources, there must be some third party interested groups or extremists behind it,” Chebotarev said. He also believes that considering the number of people that gathered for the event -- 2000 people -- preventive measures should have been taken instead of “quenching” the fire after it started.

Andrey Chebotarev. ©Yaroslav Radlovskiy

Andrey Chebotarev. ©Yaroslav Radlovskiy

Late on August 31 around 2000 people gathered near Prime Plaza mall for a concert of a famous Kazakh pop singer Kairat Nurtas. The concert did not start on time and then the singer left the stage without even finishing the first song. The disappointed crowd started breaking through the fencing then raged at the parking lot and the ground floor of the mall shattering windows and crashing the equipment. The mob was using stones and glass bottles.

The damage to the concert equipment alone is estimated at more than $150 thousand.

The crowd was dispersed, the police got the situation under control and fully stopped the raging by 11:00 p.m.


By Vladimir Prokopenko from Tengrinews.kz

Views: 5    Comments: 0
preloader
Add a comment
preloader
Hal Foster
ex-Los Angeles Times journalist, journalism professor
Aleksandr Kolpakov
Observer
Azamat Joldasbekov
Professional Independent Director
Ruslan Yensebayev
Deputy Chairman of the Board, National Information Technologies JSC
Chronos and Factsheets
Timelines of various important events.
Institute of Political Solutions
www.ipr.kz
Pew Research Center
http://people-press.org
DJ David Guetta
http://www.davidguetta.com
Stanislav Kossobokov
Vice Chairman of the Board, Halyk Bank
Quotes
Statements made by Kazakhstan and foreign leaders.
Dr Zifa Auezova
ESCAS President
Kazakhstan economic and financial experts
Rakhim Oshakbayev, Bisengali Tadjiyakov, Kenzhegali Sagadiyev
Energy Experts
Didier Holleaux, Gilles Perrot, Marie Norheim
Kairbek Suleimenov
Ex-Minister of Interior Affairs of Kazakhstan
Kenneth Fairfax
U.S. Ambassador to Kazakhstan
Umirzak Shukeyev
First Deputy Prime-Minister of Kazakhstan, member of Eurasian Economic Commission
Dr. Alexander Mirtchev
Vice-President of the Royal United Services Institute for Defence and Security Studies and founder a
Kazakhstan Chronos
Timelines of various important Kazakhstan events.
General Prosecutor's Office of Kazakhstan
General Prosecutor's Office of Kazakhstan
Heat's Hottest Hunks 2012
Sexiest Men on the Planet
Safest cars 2011
Euro NCAP's Best in Class cars of 2011
Most Desirable Woman of 2012
AskMen's Most Desirable Woman of 2012
TheCoolist
The Design, Lifestyle and Luxury Community
Top-10 Popular Women of Kazakhstan
Top-10 Listing
Miss World 2012
Beauty contest
Top-20 Most Beautiful Kazakh Women
Top 20 rating by Top-Antropos
Bilateral meeting
Speeches
Trilateral announcement
Trilateral announcement
Road Police
Funny stories
Anders Behring Breivik - Profile
Norwegian terrorist
National Army Museum
Museum
60 years of British Film and Music
hmv.com - celebrating the jubilee - the best of British
Most unusual offices
A selection of most unusual creative approaches to setting up offices around the world.
London Olympics 2012
Inspire a generation, Olympic Games 27 July - 12 August
Olympics: Quotes of the day
Inspire a generation, Olympic Games 27 July - 12 August
Zulfiya Chinshanlo
Olympic Champion - 53kg Weightlifting
Yerlan Karin
Secretary of Nur Otan party, political expert
Instability and its faces
Opinions, overviews, reseach and analysis
Prince Harry
His Royal Highness Prince Henry Charles Albert David of Wales
The ATOM Project
Act now. Stop nuclear weapons testing.
Gregory Marchenko
Governor of the National Bank of Kazakhstan
Opinion
Commentary
Elections
event
Kazakhstan at Africa Eco Race
Kazakhstan’s Astana has 2 racing crews: Shagirov-Moroz (M440, T2), Sazonov-Sakhimov (Bowler, T1)
Entertainment
Have fun reading!
Nursultan Nazarbayev
President of Kazakhstan
Kazakhstan at Dakar 2013
Kazakhstan's Astana has four crews: 3 on offroaders and 1 on truck
Zhansaya Abdumalik
Kazakhstan chess player
Interview
See what they have to say
Artur Ardavichus
Pilot
Maria Shishkina
Junior tennis star
Mikhail Kukushkin
Professional Kazakhstan tennis player
Gennadiy Doroshin
UNDP/GEF Adviser
Ching-Kuo Wu
President of the International Boxing Association (AIBA)
Tanatkan Abakanov
Director of Kazakhstan Institute of Seismology
Denis Ten
Kazakhstan Figure Skater
Zhomart Yertayev
President of the Eurasian Center for Financial Consulting
Kazakhstan at Abu Dhabi Desert Challenge-2013
Kazakhstan is represented by 6 crews: 5 offroaders and 1 quad.
Chokan Laumulin
Research Fellow, Central Asian Forum, Jesus College, University of Cambridge
War Chronicles
The Great Patriotic War
Yonatan Adiri
Founder and Chief Executive Officer Diagnose.Me, innovations expert
Letters to the Editor
Letters
UNICEF Kazakhstan
The United Nations Children’s Fund in Kazakhstan
Tom Loeffler
Tom Loeffler, K2 managing director and GGG promoter
Gennady 'GGG' Golovkin
Professional boxer from Kazakhstan, WBA and IBO Middleweight Champion
Alexander Vinokourov
Professional cyclist
Nikolay Chebotko
Kazakhstan skier
Detroit Auto Show
Car show
Yulia Galysheva
Kazakhstan's best mogul skier
Music
Music reviews, ratings and picks
Andrey Golubev
Kazakhstan professional tennis player

Feature stories